TSR Living Solution Public Company LimitedSET: TSR🇹🇭 TH

Internal Control · 2024

Internal Control — Board Opinion

Introduction

The Board of Directors and management prioritize internal control, with continuous supervision and monitoring. We recognize that the internal control system is a key mechanism that enables the company to conduct business and achieve its objectives effectively and efficiently, to create long-term returns. The use of resources and asset management, financial and operational reporting are reliable. Compliance with laws, various regulations, as well as preventing or reducing risks from actions that may cause damage to the assets and reputation of the company, including performance evaluation in accordance with good corporate governance guidelines.

At the Board of Directors Meeting No. 6/2025 on February 28, 2025, the Board of Directors considered the results of the assessment of the adequacy of the company's internal control from the Audit Committee, which assigned the Internal Audit Department to assess according to the assessment form of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the report of the Audit Committee. From the assessment of the adequacy of the company's internal control system, the Board of Directors is of the opinion that the company's internal control system is adequate and appropriate.

However, from the list of the group and the company's non-compliance with the rules on related party transactions of the Securities and Exchange Commission, in the case of borrowing money from related persons and using the assets of the group and the company to guarantee related persons, including the group and the company using the borrowed money for the wrong purpose, the Audit Committee has identified issues to improve internal control systems and supervision, such as improving the company's intercompany transaction policy and preparing an intercompany transaction manual to be used as a guideline for practice and checks and balances of authorization by requiring joint signatures with at least one non-executive director, etc. The management has urgently remedied and improved the situation in accordance with the guidelines and preventive measures. including assigning a responsible unit to supervise and monitor the internal control system to be consistently effective. In order for the operation to be efficient, the reports prepared are accurate, reliable, and the operation complies with relevant laws and regulations. It can protect the company's assets from misuse by authorized persons and related persons. Including conducting transactions with persons who may have conflicts of interest and related persons adequately. The internal audit unit also reviewed the company's internal control system according to the risk-based audit plan, which recommended improvements to internal controls. The management has prioritized improvements and found no material weaknesses in the internal control system that could affect the achievement of the organization's main objectives.

Summary of the Board's Opinion on Internal Control

The Board of Directors and the Audit Committee have emphasized to the management the importance of performing their duties and prioritizing the internal control system, especially regarding related party transactions. Although the company has had an internal control system in place, it may not have been strictly enforced and monitored for effectiveness. However, the company has improved the internal control system and established procedures to be used as guidelines for operations and to monitor the progress of management's requests for approval of various transactions to ensure correctness and compliance with the approved objectives.


For transactions that may be related to offenses related to the duties and responsibilities of the Board of Directors and management under the Securities and Exchange Act, including non-compliance w Thailand, the company will conith related party transactions or transactions that may involve conflicts of interest in accordance with the law and the regulations of the Stock Exchange ofsider the facts in conjunction with legal counsel to determine the next course of action.





Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System

Internal Control Framework Used

FrameworkDetail
COSO - Enterprise Risk Management Framework (ERM)

The Board of Directors and management have the direct responsibility to establish and maintain an internal control system. This system will encompass financial, operational, corporate governance, and risk management controls. Therefore, the Board of Directors has assigned the Audit Committee the authority and responsibility to review the company's financial reporting for accuracy and adequacy, to review the company's internal control and internal audit systems for appropriateness and effectiveness, to review the company's risk assessment and risk management for appropriateness, and to review compliance with the Securities and Exchange Act, the Stock Exchange of Thailand's regulations, and laws related to the company's business.


The company has established written guidelines for financial authority and approval limits to define responsibilities, decision-making authority, and command at all levels of position. The company has a policy of reviewing these guidelines annually to ensure they are appropriate for future business conditions.


The Board of Directors has assessed the company's internal control system based on the results of the Audit Committee's review, which was conducted in conjunction with the Internal Audit Department. The assessment concluded that, based on the five components significant to the effectiveness of internal control, the company's internal control system is:

1) Control Environment: The Board of Directors has established written policies and guidelines for operations, communicated through email announcements and the company's website. The Board oversees management and employees within the organization to perform their duties with integrity and in strict compliance with the company's rules and regulations. There is a process for monitoring results from the compliance and risk management unit and the internal audit department.

2) Risk Assessment

The Board identifies and assesses risks in 5 areas:

1) Strategic Risk

2) Financial Risk

3) Operational Risk

4) Legal and Regulatory Risk

5) Environmental Risk

The company appoints a risk management working group responsible for monitoring, tracking, reviewing, and reporting to the Risk Management Committee on a regular basis. The company also requires management to report on plans to manage risks that may affect the achievement of the organization's objectives, to prevent and mitigate potential losses, and to prepare for all situations.

3) Control Activities: The company requires management and employees to operate in accordance with written policies and regulations, covering various processes such as setting limits and approval authority for each level of management. The company should review and update policies by type of control activity to ensure they remain appropriate, as follows:

• Preventive Controls: To prevent risks and errors from occurring in the first place.

• Detective Controls: To detect errors that have already occurred.

• Corrective Controls: To correct errors that have occurred or to find ways to prevent them from recurring in the future.

• Directive Controls: To promote or encourage success directly related to the desired objectives.

4) Information & Communication: The management is required to prepare detailed information on the matters presented, such as objectives, scope of approval authority, and impact on the company, with accuracy and completeness. Relevant employees should have access to or be informed of the information, including the recording of details to allow for retrospective verification of the performance of directors and management.

• Management must use information to support their decision-making.

• Employees must use information to guide their work.

5) Monitoring Activities

A process for monitoring and evaluation is established by assigning the management to report on the progress of requests for approval or outstanding issues. Regular monthly meetings of the Audit Committee and the Board of Directors are held to ensure that deficiencies and issues are fully addressed and rectified.

Internal Control Deficiencies

Number of Deficiencies

MetricCurrent YearPrevious YearTwo Years Ago
Total number of internal control system deficiencies (cases)100

Deficiency Details

Period TypeStart Period (YYYY-MM)End Period (YYYY-MM)DetailProgress StatusCorrective Action
month/year Range2023-032024-03
The group and the company did not comply with the rules on connected transactions of the Securities and Exchange Commission, in cases of borrowing money from connected persons and using the assets of the group and the company to guarantee connected persons, including the group and the company using the borrowed money for purposes other than intended.
Incident no longer subject to action

1. Improve the company's related party transaction policy and prepare a manual for related party transactions to be used as a guideline and to prevent potential errors. This includes announcing its use and communicating it to relevant parties. Version 1, Effective Date August 14, 2024.

2. In the case of completed related party transactions, the relevant management/department shall prepare a report summarizing the performance and utilization according to the objectives within 30 days and report it to the Executive Committee and the Board of Directors.

3. The risk management and administration department provides advice and reviews transactions before entering into related party transactions. This includes monitoring the corrective actions taken by the management and reporting them to the Risk Committee regularly.

4. Provide for the review of related party transactions in accordance with the audit plan. The internal audit department must report to the Audit Committee and have control measures in place to inspect, monitor, and ensure that random reviews of transactions are conducted accurately, fairly, and in accordance with the specified conditions, policies, or terms.

5. Balance of approval by requiring that the authorized signatory according to the company's letter of authorization must co-sign with at least one non-executive director.

Audit Committee & Auditor Observations

Audit Committee's Opinion Differs from the Board's

No

Auditor Has Observations on Internal Control

No

Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

Head of Internal Audit

3159

Audit Committee's Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

The Audit Committee considers and reviews the scope of work, responsibilities, and annual work plan of the Internal Audit Department. The committee has appointed Ms. Pitchayaphone Kongsanam, Head of Internal Audit of TSR Living Solution Public Company Limited, to be responsible for overseeing the company's internal audit function. This appointment is based on her knowledge, capabilities, and suitability to perform such duties with due care and diligence. Furthermore, she possesses independence, experience in internal audit work, and has received training in relevant internal audit and audit supervision courses to meet international standards. The Audit Committee is responsible for reviewing the annual internal audit plan, internal audit reports, and following up on internal audit findings with management. The committee also provides guidance to internal auditors to ensure that the internal audit plan is carried out effectively and efficiently.

Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit

Requires Audit Committee Approval

Yes

Description

The Audit Committee considers the independence of the Internal Audit unit, including its structure, the appointment, transfer, and annual performance evaluation of the Head of Internal Audit. The committee also considers the adequacy of the Internal Audit unit's budget and personnel. Furthermore, the Audit Committee provides recommendations for the consideration of rewards and penalties for the Head of Internal Audit. The committee may also appoint a fact-finding committee to investigate the Head of Internal Audit in cases where the Head of Internal Audit is accused of misconduct under the law or company regulations. This includes overseeing the company's good governance and business ethics.

Related Party Transactions

Has Related Party Transactions

Yes

Counterparties & Transactions

Monetary Unit

1000000

Counterparties with Potential Conflicts

NamePerson / Juristic PersonType of BusinessNature of RelationshipAs of Date (YYYY-MM-DD)
Better Dreams Co., Ltd.Juristic PersonHolding company

A major shareholder of TSR, held 19.54% of registered and paid up share capital

2024-12-31T00:00
Sabuy Technology Public Company LimitedJuristic PersonBusiness of selling automatic top-up machines and providing financial transaction services through automatic top-up machines.

From 1 January 2024 to 27 April 2024: Had a major shareholder of the company holding 24.92% of the Company's shares.

From 27 April 2024 onwards, there is 1 joint director, Mr. Viruch Morakotkarn.

2024-12-31T00:00
Nakhonluang Capital Public Company LimitedJuristic PersonProviding financial support to small to medium sized enterprises

From January 1, 2024, to April 27, 2024, the shares were held by SABUY, which is the major shareholder of the company, holding 25.00% of the paid-up capital.

From April 27, 2024, onwards, there is 1 joint director, Mr. Viruch Morakotkarn.

2024-12-31T00:00
Ideal Water Co., LtdJuristic PersonManufacture and distribute drinking water

It is a company where family members are closely related to key executives.

2024-12-31T00:00
Drink Co Co.,Ltd.Juristic PersonSale of water filters and related products, as well as electrical appliances

It is a company where family members are closely related to key executives.

2024-12-31T00:00

Transactions by Counterparty

Transactions
0.04 · Necessity: The mentioned arrangement is necessary and reasonable because the company currently has the capacity to provide services and store information for the information technology (IT) system. Leasing this IT system will help partially allocate the costs associated with it. The lease agreement includes clearly defined security standards for the IT system, as well as the service period and fees. In the event that the company requires additional IT services, the lease agreement can be terminated immediately. · Description: TSR provided information system service to Better Dreams Co., Ltd. · As of yesteryear: 0.06 · Nature of transaction: Revenues from information system service · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee has approved it because it is beneficial to the company and the pricing is appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.06 · 0.01 · Necessity: The company has unused space from its operations, so it has divided the space for rent, with rental prices set close to the market rates in the surrounding area. · Description: The company leases office space at its headquarters and factory space to Better Dreams Co., Ltd. · As of yesteryear: 0.12 · Nature of transaction: Rental Income from building · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee has approved it because there is unused space that can generate additional income, and the rental price is set in line with general market rates. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.12
0.0 · Necessity: The mentioned arrangement is necessary and reasonable because there are only a few manufacturers and distributors of magnesium water in Thailand. The customer base of Safe Trade International Co., Ltd. has a demand for this product. The commercial terms set between the parties will also allow Safe Trade International Co., Ltd. to resell the product and earn a reasonable profit. · Description: Safe Trade International Co., Ltd. was appointed by Ideal Water Co., Ltd. as a distributor to sale water to TSR’s customers. Safe Trade International Co., Ltd. purchased water from Ideal Water Co., Ltd. for selling to TSR’s customers. · As of yesteryear: 0.06 · Nature of transaction: Purchasing drinking water · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee has approved it because it is part of the company's normal business operations, under the same commercial terms as with other business partners. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.12 · 0.0 · Necessity: The mentioned arrangement is necessary and reasonable because the purchase of water is for serving as a beverage for internal company events and is beneficial to health. · Description: The company purchases drinking water from Ideal Water Co., Ltd. to serve at internal company events and to sell to employees. · As of yesteryear: 0.64 · Nature of transaction: Purchasing drinking water · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee has approved it because it is part of the company's normal business operations, under the same commercial terms as with other business partners. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.02 · 1.5 · Necessity: The interest rate is based on market rates, and the collateral is provided as per standard practice. · Description: Loan from Safe Trade International Co.,Ltd. · As of yesteryear: 1.54 · Nature of transaction: Loan · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee has approved it because the interest rate is based on market rates, and the collateral is provided as per standard practice. · As of year before yesteryear: 1.15 · 0.03 · Necessity: The company's factory has some unused space, and the lease will not impact the company's production processes. Additionally, the terms and rental price are in accordance with market rates. · Description: The company leases a 200-square-meter area for product manufacturing to Ideal Water Co., Ltd. · As of yesteryear: 0.12 · Nature of transaction: Rental Income from building · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee has approved it because there is unused space that can generate additional income, and the rental price is set in line with general market rates. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.12 · 0.01 · Necessity: It is utility income related to the leasing of factory buildings. · Description: The company charges utility fees based on the actual expenses incurred. · As of yesteryear: 0.06 · Nature of transaction: Utilities Income · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee has approved it because it is utility fees related to the leasing of factory buildings, and the price is based on the actual expenses incurred. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.04
4.24 · Necessity: It is the normal course of business for the company, with the selling price determined based on cost plus an added profit margin. · Description: The company sells water filters and other products to Drink Co., Ltd. · As of yesteryear: 0.45 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee approved the matter as it is part of the company's normal business operations, under standard commercial terms. · As of year before yesteryear: 4.0
945.67 · Necessity: The company is in the process of reviewing the facts in collaboration with legal advisors to determine the next course of action. · Description: Short-term loan from Sabuy Technology Public Company Limited · As of yesteryear: 937.82 · Nature of transaction: Short-term loans and accrued interest · Audit committee opinion: N/A · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
45.0 · Necessity: The company is in the process of reviewing the facts in collaboration with legal advisors to determine the next course of action. · Description: Short term loans from Nakornluang Capital Public Company Limited · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Short term loans · Audit committee opinion: N/A · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0

Policy & Future Trends

Future Trends in Related Party Transactions

For any potential connected transactions, directors shall comply with relevant rules. A director has no right to have a vote on approval of any transaction that he/she may have potential conflict of interest. In addition, the director is required to declare to the Board of Directors if there is any transaction that he/she may have conflict of interest. In case the Audit Committee shall provide their opinions in regard to the appropriateness of the connected transactions that the members of the Audit Committee have no expertise in those particular transactions, the Company will seek opinions from independent experts, e.g., an auditor, an independent asset appraiser. The opinions from the independent experts shall be used as part of a decision making process of the Board of Directors and/or shareholders, whichever the case may be, in order to ensure that the connected transactions are not intended to transfer benefits to other company or individual, and that they are aimed at maximizing the benefits for all shareholders.

• Normal transactions or transactions aimed at supporting the Company’s core business, with general trade terms and conditions, include services, sale and purchases of products. The Company has a policy to set terms and conditions of connected transactions based on the normal trading at the market prices. The prices are comparable to the prices offered to third parties and all parties seriously follow the terms and conditions in the agreement. The pricing and conditions are transparently and fairly set, not enabling anyone to exchange or transfer benefits. The internal auditor is in charge of reviewing the information and completing a report to be submitted to the Audit Committee. The report shall indicate the appropriateness of the prices and the justification of the transactions on a quarterly basis.

• Normal transactions and transactions aimed at supporting the Company’s core business, without general trade terms, and other related transactions include leases of offices and financial support, e.g., borrowing, guaranteeing and etc. The Company has a policy to propose such transactions to the Board of Directors’ meetings for approval. The Audit Committee shall present in the meeting and provide their opinions in regard to the justification and the necessity of such transactions before the Company can proceed with such transactions. In addition, the Company shall comply with relevant laws about securities and the stock market and the rules, notifications, orders or regulations of the Stock Exchange of Thailand. The Company also follows the rules relating to disclosure of connected transactions and the acquisitions and disposal of major assets of the Company or subsidiaries (if any). The Company also complies with the accounting standard in regard to the disclosure of information relating to individuals or connected transactions; the accounting standard is announced by Federation of Accounting Professions. The Company discloses the connected transactions in the note to financial statements of the Company as well as in the annual report.(From 56-1 One Report).

The future connected transactions will include those aimed at supporting the Company’s core business transactions, e.g., selling and buying products. Also, in the future the Company may need to provide further assistance to its subsidiaries in terms of the deposit guaranteeing and/or lending. Any potential transactions shall be completed. with transparency and strictly in compliance with the regulations of the Securities and Exchange Commission, the Stock Exchange of Thailand and other agencies.

Contents